"Chapter 8" "Misuzu Cooking Studio" "Onee-chan?" "(older sister)" "What is she doing?" "Onee-chan?" "(Calling Misuzu)" "Is someone there?" "This is terrible." "The victim is Maeda Misuzu, age 35." "She is a culinary specialist, also one of - the proprietors of this cooking school." "How many places was she stabbed?" "The time the victim was seen last was 7:30 pm." "That's when her business partner Kanazawa Yoriko-san left here." "She said the victim stayed behind to do some work." "The motive must be originated from a grudge." "If it was a robbery, she wouldn't be stabbed so many times." "I assume the suspect entered here after 7:30." "Around 8:50, - a guard was making his rounds and heard - some noise coming from the studio, - and he used a spare key to enter." "Then, he witnessed a suspicious man." "The man escaped from this window and fell." "He was killed instantly." "His identity?" "Unfortunately, he wasn't carrying anything to identify himself." "W-what are you doing?" "As you can see, we're cooking." "Well... why are you cooking here?" "This is his hobby." "Then, please listen to me while you cook." "I'd like to consult you about the murder that occurred three days ago." "Please don't." "We are about to eat, you know." "A culinary specialist was brutally murdered." "I'm losing my appetite." "She was stabbed with a knife more than 200 times." "The suspect tried to escape and died falling out of the window." "But, he wasn't carrying any ID to show who he was." "Sensei, you have a lot of time to spare today." "Do I look like I have time to spare?" "Since this is not a part of research or anything." "If I'm not doing my research in a lab, do you think I have time to kill?" "So, if you say I have spare time if I don't work, you are simple-minded." "Do you use restroom because you are bored?" "Or take a bath or sleep because you have free time?" "I'm using my precious free time to devote myself to a hobby." "At the same time, I'm engaging in an act - of eating behavior which is necessary for survival." "In other words, I'm very busy right now." "This morning, the suspect's identity was found." "The suspect was Kosugi Koichi, age 32." "An unemployed man who lived alone in an apartment in Ota-ku." "We posted his portraits all over Tokyo, - and we finally discovered his identity." "Sensei, should I get two plates?" " Yes." "But, I couldn't find any connection between the victim and Kosugi." "There isn't enough to offer you." "But a month ago, the victim visited the South Nerima Police Station - to file a stalking report." "One of the plates is chipped." "The headquarter is considering this case as homicide." "It's horrible." "It's horrible." "I know that!" "She filed a stalking report... and it's police's error again." "Okay, it's done." "Wow, it looks so delicious." "As far as I have heard, it is a simple homicide." "So I am not interested." "Okay, let's eat." "Thank you for the meal." " Hey!" "This case alone may be ordinary, - but..." "I found something strange in the testimony - of the victim's younger sister." "My sister was standing there." "I saw her face clearly, too." "Well, do you know what time that was?" "It was 8:40." "I thought it was odd to see her standing - in the garden when it was cold." "But soon, she disappeared." "She didn't come back, so I called her cellphone 10 minutes later." "This is how her younger sister, Chiaki-san, testified." "But, this is absolutely impossible." "Impossible?" "Chiaki-san made her call at 8:50." "Right after that, a guard heard the sound and entered the crime scene." "By then, the victim was already murdered." "But she had 10 minutes." "To return to her cooking studio." "But, that's impossible." "How so?" "The distance between the place she was seen and the crime scene is 30km." "No matter what kind of transportation you use, - it will take more than an hour at least." "It's impossible to travel 30km in ten minutes." "That's why I said it's impossible." "Teleportation..." "Teleportation?" "In 1593, - in front of the soldiers guarding the Grand Palace in Mexico, - a man holding a gun appeared suddenly." "He said he was guarding the residence - of the governor of Manila a moment ago." "And he started to talk about an incident - in Manila which no Mexicans knew about." "Yukawa-sensei." " In 1630s, - a nun in Spain, Mary, - teleported to Central America several times." "Her missionary work left many footprints." "In 1655, there was a story of a man who was executed by fire, - because he teleported from Goa, India to Portugal." "You must be kidding." "How people can teleport..." "Like these cases, - there are cases reported all over the world, - that people traveled a long distance - instantaneously, or in a short period of time." "How could this happen...?" "That intrigues me a lot." "Are you saying she actually teleported?" "I'm not sure, but it's amusing if she did." "Indeed amusing." "Galileo Seeing a ghost" "Timing and Subtitles brought to you by Criminal Minds Team in @ viki" "The victim filed a police report against a stalker, - but it didn't prevent this tragedy from happening." "Police is to be blamed for ignoring the claim of a stalker victim." "TV reporters are here again." "Geez, why did they set up an investigation headquarter here?" "We will have extra work, like preparing for - a press conference to apologize to the public." "We still have tons of investigation left, - but do we still have to hold a press conference?" "For a case like this, it's better to apologize as soon as possible - and close it." "The culprit is Kosugi for sure." "Don't worry about trivial things." "It can't be helped." "I feel sorry for Jonouchi-san though." "Is something wrong with Jonouchi-san?" "Oh?" "You don't know?" "The victim was Jonouchi-san's acquaintance." "What?" "You... don't even think about doing something reckless." "Don't stir things up meaninglessly." "Police is police, I am me." "It's not my business to interfere with the process of investigations." "But..." "This is not something you should be worrying about." "Her younger sister said something odd." "Chiaki-chan did?" "At the estimated time of the crime, - she said she saw her sister where she couldn't be." "Under the normal circumstances, it's impossible." "I also have requested Yukawa-sensei to assist us on this case." "Galileo-sensei?" "He said this was done by teleportation." "At our station, some say it was a ghost." "A ghost, huh." "I was inconsiderate." "I'm sorry." "About five years ago, I started to take cooking lessons at her studio." "Well, I was horrible at cooking." "But, I got along with her very well." "From that time on, - she was a very close friend to me." "I don't believe in ghosts." "Ghosts can't tell us anything." "Finding out the last thing the deceased person said before dying." "Listening to the message that remains in the corpse." "That's my job." "I won't ever forgive you people." "Please wait." "Let's talk." "There's nothing else for me to talk about." "If you had caught the stalker, - my sister wouldn't have died." "I'm very sorry about that, so..." "Police only have excuses." "They say that there weren't any suspicious people around her, - and they couldn't imagine this kind of thing would happen." "I don't want to hear that anymore." "I'll be talking with my lawyer from now on." "I want to know what you saw." "I'm concerned about your testimony." "But, no matter how you think, isn't it improbable - that my sister came back?" " Right." "At this point, the police can't use your eyewitness report as evidence." "That was my sister without any doubt." "Because the police didn't do anything for her, - my sister's spirit probably became a ghost to convey what she felt." "I don't really care if the police believes me or not." "I believe that you saw something." "Please, let me listen to your story." "Normally, we didn't live together, - but recently, since my sister told me she was being bothered by a stalker, " "I would sometimes go stay at her place." "I felt like I might have a cold that day." "After entering her house, without realizing it, I fell asleep at the - kotatsu. (A kotatsu is a table that warms your legs underneath.) " "Onee-chan." "Can you reasonably think that it might have - been your own reflection you saw in the window?" "No, I can't." "It was dark in the room because I had turned off the lights." "What about the possibility that you saw something else?" "Absolutely not." "I could clearly see her facial expression - and the yellow coat she was wearing." "In fact, the victim was wearing a yellow coat." "Well, I'm glad that you believe my story, but..." "It's my job to investigate anything, no matter what." "I am only interested in solving matters that are mysterious." "I don't believe for a second that what you saw was a ghost." "Yukawa-sensei." "It would be illogical to simply accept the existence of a ghost." "Then what do you think I saw?" "!" "I don't know." "That's why we need to investigate." "It's cold!" "For sure the distance is not enough to make you mistake what you see." "I can clearly see your facial expression too." "Why do you think she was standing in the garden?" "Then maybe it was a ghost after all?" "With what intention?" "Hmm, I don't know." "Maybe she wanted to return to her own house." "Do you seriously believe that ghosts exist?" "Eh?" "Not seriously, but wondered if they might." "Sensei?" "Don't make yourself so comfortable." "It's cold." " Because the door was open." "Give me the remote control." "Are you sensitive to the cold?" "I don't have a problem with cold, I just don't like it." "Give me the remote control." "I told you not to make yourself so comfortable." "I absolutely don't believe in anything like ghosts." "I'm very aware of that." "The reason is that there is the contradiction that a ghost - doesn't appear unless there's a person there to see it." "That a mysterious phenomenon occurs on the premise that someone is watching - is a problem of cognitive psychology." "So how did Chiaki-san know - that her sister was wearing a yellow coat?" "Was it just a coincidence?" "Are you really thinking that it was teleportation?" "The cause of Misuzu-san's death was loss of blood." "There were two fatal wounds - out of the 270 stab wounds." "And it seems that the shape of the weapon in the - two fatal wounds is different from the others." "What do you mean?" "Outside of the two fatal wounds, there were - no vital reaction in the other wounds." "After the two fatal wounds were made, - the other 268 wounds were most likely inflicted - using a different knife." "Those 268 wounds were inflicted - with the knife that Kosugi was carrying, right?" "But we haven't found the weapon that matches the two fatal wounds yet." "Does that mean that someone took the other knife and left?" "I don't know." "Maybe I just don't want to think that - it was a simple case of a homicide by a stalker." "I was also consulted by Misuzu-san - about being followed by someone and getting phone - calls with no one speaking on the other end." "But in the end, I didn't do anything for her." "It's not your fault, Jonouchi-san." "The central police station is trying to close this case - concluding she was murdered by the stalker - before the criticism grows louder." "But I'll continue to investigate other possibilities." "Even if by myself, I'll get to the bottom of it." "Oh?" "I see." "I'll leave the rest to you then." "As the medical examiner, I've explained - the wounds I found on Misuzu-san's body." "For what comes next, I'm depending on you." "I understand." "This is the person..." "Hmmm, unless it's a regular customer, I can't remember everyone's face." "Is that right?" "Thank you." "Sir!" "Don't do that, it's dangerous!" "Sir!" "Stop that, it's dangerous!" "I told you many times." "That guy just stayed alone at home." "He hardly ever came out." "As long as someone pays the rent on time, " "I don't pay attention to how they live." "Excuse me." "Chiaki-san." " Detective!" "What's up?" "I'm going over the events once more ...what is everyone doing?" "Since this place is going to be closed, - they came to help clean up." "Oh, really?" "Then, can we just speak for a moment?" "Sensei, no matter what you use, you can't - travel thirty kilometers in ten minutes." "That's enough for now." "You have to check the students' work." "Ok." "OK, one at a time." "Come over here." "This way." "It's a matter of Murasa and Miyuki-san earning their credits." "Their graduation is at stake." "Are you listening to me, Sensei?" "Yes." "Please." "The Nature of Space and Time Hawking and Penrose" "There's definitely something wrong with that." "Isn't it the first time to see him reading books like that?" "He doesn't believe on cults." "The other day I heard him muttering to himself, saying " ""How is the 'teleportation door'* constructed?"" "(* one of tools that Doraemon, an animation character, uses) " "He is getting quite eccentric." "We were previously asked by the police to check around, - but we didn't find any missing knives or kitchen utensils." "Well, I see." "Um, when Kanazawa-san left at 7:30, - there was definitely no one here but Misuzu-san, right?" "Absolutely." "We all leave at 6:30 when the lesson is over." "I always stay until about 7:30 to take care of paperwork, - but Misuzu-sensei sometimes stayed late to work on new recipes." "Sometimes she stayed here overnight." "She was a hard-working teacher." "How could this happen...?" "Sensei." "Yukawa-sensei, considering the possibility - that his accomplice took the murder weapon, " "I checked Kosugi's background." "But, he had no one in his life." "No parents or siblings." "I couldn't find single person he was friend with." "It's hard to believe he had an accomplice." "We are certain about the culprit, and yet - there are so many mysteries about this case." "Agree." " Huh?" "I can't figure out how she traveled 30km in 10 minutes." "I have no idea." "But I am certain about one thing." "There is something hidden in this case." "The ghost that was witnessed and the mystery of the victims' wounds, - are connected somehow." "What makes you think that?" "It's a hunch for being a detective." "It's an illogical theory, indeed." "Sensei, you don't have time to be involved in this case anymore." "No... that might not be true." "What?" "Hunch is different from assumption." "Even the remarkable achievements of Issac Newton, - it was only his hunch in the beginning." "When he was in his early 20s, he discovered many important theories." "He proved his theories were correct by - experimenting based on his assumptions." "So your hunch can lead you to discover the fact." "Now I know what to do." "Um... what do you mean by that?" "Based on your hunch, let's confirm one by one." "At first, we need to find out more about Kosugi." "Understood." "Not interesting at all." "It's cold, so let's go inside." "We couldn't find any evidence from this room to point out that " "Kosugi was stalking Misuzu-san." "From the beginning, he planned on killing himself - after killing Misuzu-san." "That could be the - reason he got rid of all the evidence." "Sensei?" "It is all receipts from Catalog orders or Internet shopping." "It seems like he didn't leave this room that often." "He doesn't have any close friends - or it doesn't look like he had any guests over." "This is...!" "What did you find?" "Fantastic." " What is it?" "Audio Classic Style from Luxman." " What?" "Vacuum tube Amplifer that was released after 11 years." "And?" "I also wanted this." "What a wonderful sound." "Why did we come here for?" "To find out what kind of a person Kosugi is." "What does that have anything to do with this Audio machine?" "Do you find anything out by knowing his favorite type of music?" "We are going to investigate one by one based on my hunch, right?" "Hello?" "Hello?" "I got it." "You ignore me?" "Oops, I am sorry." "Agh!" "What is it?" "What kind of hairstyle did Kosugi have?" "Long or short hair?" "Short hair." "Shaved." "What does that have anything to do with it...?" "Sensei?" "Sensei?" "How can you travel 30 km in 10 minutes?" "Then what do you think I saw?" "!" "Teleportation?" "This is the only way." "Did you find out anything?" "There sure is another side to this case." "...and" " And?" "Chiaki-san's testimony is not true." "That means..." " I'll explain later." "Before that, I need you to confirm something." "Sensei!" "..." "Shoes." "I don't know why Yukawa-sensei is late." "I heard that you found the truth about the case, but why are we here?" "This is what Yukawa-sensei requested." "However, I don't know the details." "I am sorry." "On top of that, he is late." "He is rude." "Don't mind me." "Ah, I should go look around the station." "He might be lost." "Can you stay here?" " Yes." "I will be back soon." "I am sorry, I am late." "Ah, the detective just left to get you." "Ah, we must have missed each other." "She is always so clumsy." "If we wait for her, it will be late." "Let's begin without her." "Please excuse me." "After the police questioned people around here, - they found some witnesses who saw a person with a yellow coat on - just like you testified." "That person was spotted - at the nearby arcade by 3 different people." "Is that so?" "It is true that there was someone like that." "Chiaki-san." "But that was not your sister." "The person whom you saw was someone else." "You thought that was your sister." "That is not true." "I saw her face." "You saw the yellow coat and thought it was her." "You were biased." "Not true." " The yellow coat... was Misuzu-san's favorite." "You knew that, so you misunderstood." "That is not true." "I really saw her..." "You didn't see the face." "How can you be so sure?" "There is no way you could see it." "Look at this window closely." "You can see dew condensation." "On the night you said you saw Misuzu- san, the temperature was 8 degrees." "It was colder than today." "Windows of this room which had heater on, - must have had dew condensation." "How can you see the face or the facial expression - of Mizusu-san who was supposed to be in the yard?" "There are some numbers on the sketchbook - that the person has." "Can you see?" "Of course you didn't lie on purpose." "However..." "Wait a second." "That is not right." "Even though I can't see the numbers, " "I can tell who that person is." "Who is it?" "It is the detective, right?" "Please do not get upset." "This is just a phychological test." "Having seen Utsumi-kun with a red coat on, - and based on your memory of the color, - you thought this was her." "Your brain has stored something that you didn't see." "I am sorry to say that it is such an unscientific fantasy - to think that Misuzu-san became a ghost and came to see you." "Then, who was that?" "This is a whole different case that the culprit tried - to make it look like a murder committed by a stalker." "The person in a yellow coat you saw wasn't Misuzu-san." "The person was the perpetrator who murdered Misuzu-san." "Probably the incident occurred accidentally." "The culprit killed Misuzu-san unintentionally - and tried to cover up the crime." "The reason why the culprit appeared here wearing - a yellow coat on the day of the murder... was that the culprit wanted the neighbors - to acknowledge Misuzu-san came home." "For what purpose?" "If everything went well according to the plan, " "Misuzu-san's body wouldn't have been discovered until the next morning." "The murder would be discovered in the morning." "Then, the police would question people around this neighborhood - and find witnesses who saw a person in a yellow coat." "Base on the testimony, the police would assume - that Misuzu-san came home, then returned to the cooking studio - and was murdered there." "So the estimated time of her death, - considering the time it would take to travel, - would be at least after 9:30 pm." "But the culprit has an alibi around that time." "Faked an alibi?" "I had a wrong idea about this." "I thought the culprit had a certain - purpose to appear in front of Chiaki-san." "However, it was too risky - for an impostor to show up - in front of Chiaki-san, her sister." "I couldn't figure out why it was necessary to do so." "But it's only natural that I couldn't figure it out, - because the plan was ruined in the middle." "Ruined?" "The culprit didn't imagine that - there was a person in this house who knew Misuzu-san's face very well." "Onee-chan?" "(older sister)" "The culprit looked inside the house and fled being stunned." "What did Kosugi have to do with this?" "He wasn't a stalker." "He was called over by the culprit to disguise the murder." "Perhaps, Kosugi and the culprit had a close relationship." "There was firm evidence - that a woman visited Kosugi's residence frequently." "Wait a minute." "I searched it but didn't see anything." "That's because the culprit eliminated all the visible evidence from there." "The cuplrit hadn't anticipated that Kosugi would fall and die." "That's why she was in a hurry - to eliminate all her traces from his house." "To pin the crime on Kosugi." "What do you mean by "she"?" "Do you already know the real culprit?" "It is a person who needed to fake an alibi." "If you think logically, you should know the answer." "When Misuzu-san's body was discovered in the cooking studio - the following morning, who would be suspected the most?" "That means..." "The person who saw Misuzu-san last." "It can't be..." "The culprit is..." "Kanazawa Yoriko." "The person who has been harassing Misuzu-san was Kanazawa Yoriko." "Since Misuzu-san was talented and attracted everyone's attention, - she has been jealous of Misuzu-san for a long time." "Misuzu-san realized her harassment and confronted her." "Kanazawa Yoriko stabbed Misuzu-san with a knife abruptly." "She panicked and called Kosugi over to her place." "Kosugi and Yoriko met on a dating site." "Since she has too much of self-respect, - she didn't tell anyone about the relationship with Kosugi." "She was paying for his living expenses, - and in return, she was treating Kosugi as if he were a pet." "Kosugi was lonely, so he obeyed her unconditionally." "Like that, their relationship was rather odd." "After Yoriko fled, Kosugi stayed behind at the crime scene, - he stabbed Misuzu-san's body multiple times to - make it look like a gory murder done by a stalker." "Yoriko fled, then, in order to confuse the estimated time of death, - she headed to Misuzu-san's house - wearing a yellow coat." "She knew the similar yellow coat - was in the office of the cooking studio." "Rest of the story is just as you said." "Wait." "Why are you cooking here?" "This..." "Jonouchi-san gave me this book." "Thank you very much." "I didn't do anything particular." "Sakurako-san, you delivered - my sister's final message." "So the detective said." "Utsumi-san did?" " Yes." "I... truly believed - that I saw my sister, looking at the culprit." "I am really grateful to know the truth." "It's been a while, but I might cook it..." "It's the only dish Misuzu-san approved of, among all the things I've made." "Since it's getting cold lately, the dish would warm me up." "Do you want to join me tonight, Chiaki-chan?" "Sure." "Ah... sorry, I'll clean up later." "Can you do this at home?" "How did you find out about - the relationship between Yoriko and Kosugi?" "Before Kosugi got identified, Yoriko took - out all of her belongings out of his place." "You're putting too much salt." "Don't mess with me." "There was no trace that a woman was in the room." "Gari." "Pickled ginger?" "You mean for sushi?" "No." "When I turned up the volume on the stereo at Kosugi's, - you heard some cracking sound, right?" "Yes." "It is called Gari (hum) in the music industry." "It happens when the lubricant for the switch - is linked with the silicon particles floating in the air." "And?" "According to one audio equipment manufacturer's inspection, - stereos that are supplied to love hotels, - the hum occurs much faster than usual." "And when they did research on the cause, - they figured out it was caused by the hairspray used by women." "Hair spray?" "Hair sprays have tons of silicon in them." "That's why I asked about Kosugi's hair." "Because if he has a buzzcut, he wouldn't need hairsprays." "Ah.." "That's why." "If you pay close attention, people leave their traces in many forms." "I see." "And I'm done!" "What's that?" " Eh?" "You know, pepper steak." "I'll guarantee the taste." "See!" "It's delicious." "Here." "No, thank you." " Why?" "There's no way it is delicious." "You have to try before you say that." "The "Si" from "Qing jiao rou si" (pepper steak) means thinly sliced." "This is definitely not thinly sliced." "It doesn't matter because it's delicious." "Cooking is science." "The change that occurs on the surface that's cut, - the timing and order in which you mix and add the ingredients, - the amount, the adjustment you make to the temperature." "The processing conditions from all of those combined decide the taste." "Cooking isn't about logic." "Just try eating it." "Just one bite." "Here." "You just thought it tasted good didn't you?" "Right, sensei?" "You definitely thought so didn't you?" "I'm eating." "Timing and Subtitles brought to you by Criminal Minds Team in @ viki" ""I don't understand myself"" ""It makes me want to cry but it's fun"" ""I am looking for an equation"" ""that will give me an answer to happiness"" ""The strength of love lies in here"" ""I'll support you even on nights when you can't laugh or cry"" ""Hey, I'll give you everything I have"" ""even "the most valued part of me" that I haven't shown to anyone"" ""Kiss these bare lips"" ""I wonder if you would laugh at me"" ""But I'll try to solve such mystery of this life"" ""Hey, I'll protect everything of you"" ""even "the honest part of you" that you haven't shown to anyone"" ""Like this, I offer you"" ""my bare lips to kiss"" ""Kiss me on my lips that have fallen in love""