"Guess who I went to second base with?" "Who, Cy?" "Lyla Smith!" "Bull!" "Get back here!" "Why don't you believe me?" "'Cause you lie!" "CY:" "I grew up normal." "In a normal house, the size of a castle." "(raucous shouts)" "I played sports..." "?" "...how sweet the sound... ?" "sang in the choir... for the President of the United States... and celebrated my birthdays with four-story cakes flown straight from Paris." "My brother and I played kickball over there." "And-and here is where we would hide from the police, after stealing magic potions from the toy store." "I don't know why they wouldn't believe me when I told them we were gonna make things with it." "I still build things now." "I took apart a 1961 DeSoto, and built a generator." "From scratch." "It's so powerful, it could light a Springsteen concert." "But for now, it just lights my room." "(chuckles)" "(woman gasping)" "Please, what are you doing?" "(sobbing):" "I don't understand." "I'll do anything." "Please, don't hurt me." "CY:" "Shh, shh, shh, shh, shh." "Shh, shh, shh." "Why would I hurt you?" "WOMAN:" "No, no, no, no, no, no!" "(screams)" "So you finished the course?" "Mm-hm." "And completed my case rotation." "Hotch says he's never seen a rookie profiler analyze and write up cases as well as you." "He said that?" "Yeah." "Well, after all the cases you've presented over the years," "I'm not surprised." "Hmm." "Hey, where have you been?" "I wanted to do brunch this weekend." "I had to deal with some stuff with my mom." "Have you seen Garcia?" "Uh, she's with Rossi." "He hates me." "(sighs)" "Mm, he was just busy." "Let it go." "Okay, you can be honest, I can take it." "Okay." "I prefer my pasta al dente." "And the pancetta was a little weird." "Oh." "That's 'cause it's tofu." "Tofu?" "I give you my recipe and you do an improv?" "No, no, I followed it down to the micron-- aside from the pig." "Look, Master of All Things Italian," "I am having a Fellini festival at my house this weekend and I must serve the beautiful food of his country." "Maybe you should show a Disney film and stick with burgers." "You know, Rossi, you could always give Penelope a cooking lesson." "Oh, my gosh, that would be amazing." "That would be like... that would be like the lron Chef meets the BAU." "And we could do it at your house." "I don't have a house." "I have a mansion." "HOTCH:" "All right, let's get started." "Oh." "All right." "Mes amis, you are jetting to Durant, Oklahoma, because in the last three days, two women have been found dead after being sexually tortured and then blinded with a sulfuric acid solution." "Abby Elcott is our first victim, 19-year-old art student." "She was heading to campus for an advanced drawing class." "She'd been missing for two days." "Same goes with our second victim, Beth Westerly, 17." "She had just finished her coffee shop shift and was on her way to a bar method class." "Both low-risk victims." "MORGAN:" "And physically similar." "How close are the two abduction sites?" "Five miles apart at bus stops." "Abby's cell was found near one," "Beth's scarf near the other." "Where were the dump sites?" "GARClA:" "One in an alley, the other in a field." "So he stapled their eyes open, then he blinded them?" "MORGAN:" "It's about power and control." "Maybe he didn't want them to watch while he hurt 'em." "Or it could be about shame." "Perhaps the unsub is disfigured himself." "Blinding the victims leaves them helpless, lost, totally dependent." "Maybe a manifestation of how he sees himself in this world." "It is a form of enucleation, just without the scalpel." "His face is the last they see before darkness." "HOTCH:" "Garcia, come up with a list of jobs that would give the unsub access to sulfuric acid." "The rest of us, wheels up in 30 minutes." "And this is where my brother lives now." "(chuckles)" "There you are, Cy." "WOMAN:" "I got your clothes." "Bought you some shampoo and toothpaste." "See?" "We're the perfect American story." "MAN:" "Yeah, yeah, okay." "Turn that thing off." "Come on in." "Come on." "Every story has a beginning, but the part I like best... is the end." "(gasping)" "(screaming)" "RElD: "lf it is a miracle, any sort of evidence will answer, but if it is a fact, proof is necessary. "" "Mark Twain." "HOTCH:" "The victimology is very similar." "Blonde-haired, blue-eyed teenage girls." "We believe they were each abducted near public transportation stops." "When was this photo taken?" "MORGAN:" "Beth was caught on a bank surveillance camera three hours before she disappeared." "That's a recent photo of Abby." "So she wasn't found in the same clothes she was abducted in." "ROSSl:" "Maybe he changed them because hers were burned by the sulfuric acid." "RElD:" "It's possible." "Sulfuric acid can turn human flesh into soap." "HOTCH:" "Garcia, any recent similar cases" "in the surrounding area?" "garcia:" "Actually, yes." "Two months ago, a prostitute and a runaway were both found raped and killed, and they had stab wounds to their eyes." "So maybe he practiced on high-risk victims first." "And then advanced to chemical enucleation." "Isn't that a rare paraphilia?" "PRENTlSS:" "Well, the chemical part is." "It would exacerbate the pain." "Like Ed Kemper, he's probably practicing on surrogates before going after the real object of his rage." "HOTCH:" "Dave, you and I will talk to the parents," "Morgan and Prentiss, go to the disposal sites." "JJ, you and Reid to the abduction sites." "RElD:" "So, Beth got off the bus here and headed northwest toward class." "JJ:" "It's amazing no one witnessed her abduction." "Emily was buried six feet under and wound up in Paris, so I guess anything is possible, right?" "So that is what this is about." "You know, maybe our unsub's a little bit like Bundy and he feigned an injury in order to get her to help him." "Spence, if you want to talk about..." "Maybe he tried another tactic." "and was like," ""Wow, you're really pretty." "You should be a model." "I can take your photo."" "I'll take that as a no." "Either one would disarm her." "Charm's quite the killer." "So are tears." "Whatever his ruse was, the unsub most likely used it to get her into his vehicle." "Well, if Abby was last seen at a bus stop a few miles away, then he definitely has means of transportation." "Hopefully, the disposal site will tell us more." "MORGAN:" "So what do you have, Detective Bonner?" "Beth's body was found over there." "Boy, you smell the urine?" "Thought that was air freshener." "There's drugstore food everywhere." "It's a homeless corridor." "Abby was found in a shanty town as well." "So... our unsub hunts and travels through the areas unnoticed, blending in with his surroundings." "MORGAN:" "This guy's either homeless, or appears to be." "He most likely has a car to get them from the abduction site to here." "Just because you're homeless doesn't mean you're car-less." "Could explain why he chose high-risk victims at first." "They were all around him." "He had her for two days?" "I can't even imagine what she went through." "Why did he blind her?" "That's what we're trying to figure out." "I know this is difficult, but..." "I need you to look at the clothes that Abby was wearing when we found her." "Do you recognize them?" "ROSSl:" "Do you find anything odd about Beth's clothing?" "They're not Abby's." "You sure?" "I saw her that morning." "She had on a brown and pink sweater." "Beth wouldn't wear denim shorts." "They aren't her style." "You sure?" "In addition to the blinding, taking their clothes further robs them of their identity." "He's either keeping their garments as souvenirs or redressing the victims as a forensic countermeasure." "Well, dressing them in these outfits could be part of the fantasy." "Where do homeless people get their clothes?" "Churches, thrift stores." "We need to rule evertyhing out." "CY:" "Vroom..." "I'm a plane." "I'm a plane!" "You are now entering Dallas lnternational Airport." "Please hold onto your floatation device and fasten your seatbelt." "Cy, your stuff is right there." "CY:" "Oh, minty fresh." "I like minty fresh." "Well, we keep buying you toothbrushes, but you clearly aren't using them." "You know, instead of crashing here every now and again, why don't you just move in?" "CY:" "I like to be free." "Uh, last night I had a date with two hot twins." "Uh-huh, is that so?" "Why don't you believe me?" "Remember when he said he dated Cyndi Lauper in high school?" "I did!" "I did!" "I did!" "How many times do I have to tell you?" "MATT:" "A million, 'cause you always lie." "WOMAN:" "Hey, guys." "Hey, Uncle Cy." "Hi." "LYLA:" "Hey, Tammy, how was practice?" "Uh, I hit two home runs." "Oh, whoo!" "Thank you." "Hey, Mom, what's the deal with my dress?" "On your bed." "Really?" "Uh-huh." "(laughs)" "Where's she going?" "Well, Homecoming's tomorrow night." "I loved Homecoming." "MATT:" "Well, we'll be taking pictures before she leaves." "Why don't you stop by?" "Oh, and maybe I could tape it." "No, that's okay, Cy, you don't have to." "Um, why not?" "It'll be fun." "MATT:" "Well, no, what would be fun would be if you and I took a break." "I see the doctor's working." "Yeah, counseling's worth every penny." "(laughing)" "Excuse me." "Do you know where Church Street is?" "Uh, you're on Church Street." "I am?" "Uh-huh." "See, you're standing..." "Just walk." "Shh, just walk, come on." "This way, come on." "Reid and JJ went to the local thrift shop and found Abby's clothes." "So he sold them." "Or traded them for the '80s clothing." "The salesclerk said the clothes in the crime scene photos were of that time period, and he confirmed that they were purchased from his store." "So if he's getting rid of his souvenirs once he used them to remember his victims..." "Why is he fixated on this era?" "What do you got?" "The brutality the victims experienced was immense." "Multiple stab wounds to the neck and chest, plus wounds to the genitalia." "Frustration and overkill." "The same chemical damage on the skin is also around her nostrils." "M.E.:" "He poured the sulfuric acid there as well." "And that would destroy her sense of smell, yes?" "Absolutely." "He didn't do that to the first victim." "No." "He's escalating." "And blinding isn't his only signature." "No, he's... trying to take away their senses." "(woman screaming)" "I..." "I like to hear them scream." "It reminds me o-of the roller coaster." "I like roller coasters, especially in the summertime." "(chuckles)" "Somebody please help me!" "Somebody!" "(screaming)" "(muffled gasping)" "(spitting) What?" "You don't like the way I taste?" "!" "No!" "Fine." "I can help you with that!" "(whimpering)" "Somebody help me!" "Somebody please help me!" "(gasping)" "(whimpering)" "(screaming)" "No, no!" "(gurgling)" "(chuckling)" "(indistinct radio transmission)" "ROSSl:" "Again, he's disposing in an area frequented by homeless people." "RElD:" "This is equidistant between the last two dump sites." "Well, he burned her tongue with the chemical this time." "So he removed her ability to taste." "Why would he do that?" "Historically, this type of torture was used to prevent someone from revealing a secret." "JJ:" "Maybe she offended him." "Wonder what that's like." "ROSSl:" "Her lips are extremely chapped." "She was probably forced to repeatedly participate in some sort of kissing fantasy." "JJ:" "And when things go awry, he takes the offending sense away." "He tortured her in these clothes, which mean the '80s are essential to his delusion." "Maybe that's when this rejection occurred, and he held onto the clothes all these years." "And now he's attacking girls who remind him of women from that time." "RElD:" "He's fixated on her type and remakes them to fit his fantasy." "But why start now?" "JJ:" "Something probably triggered it." "Instead of dealing with it, he's acting out." "We believe the unsub or unknown subject that we're looking for is a white male in his 40s." "This is someone who's reacting to rejection by a woman when he was teenager in the 1980s." "He's punishing his victims for their reactions to him by taking away their senses with sulfuric acid." "ROSSl :" "We believe our unsub could possibly work part-time as a janitor or mechanic, which would give him access to this chemical." "MORGAN:" "And after studying the disposal site, we think it's likely that he is homeless." "Now how do we typically react toward the homeless?" "We judge them by their looks and their smells." "It's that same negative reaction we believe that a woman had toward the unsub at some point in the '80s." "The unsub's fixation on this woman is now all-consuming." "It's caused him to develop Obsessive Love Disorder." "He most likely has tunnel vision and believes that she holds the key to his happiness." "He will stalk her in an attempt to win her back." "He will do whatever it takes to be near his love interest, but her rejection will spiral him into a depression." "RElD :" "Which would lead to rape and murder of the surrogates who represent her." "And it's only a matter of time before this rage and anger 'causes the unsub to go after her directly." "girl:" "Let's go, let's fight, let's win tonight!" "Let's go, let's fight, let's win tonight!" "Let's go, let's fight..." "Lyla?" "Let's win tonight!" "(nearby laughter)" "You've got to be kidding!" "Give me a break, Cy." "Leave me alone, Matt!" "(laughing)" "Tammy?" "(gasps)" "I'm home!" "Spence, look, we've got to talk about this." "What do you mean, talk about it?" "I get it, okay?" "You're disappointed with the way we handled Emily." "Well, I have a lot going on, all right?" "You know what I think it is?" "What?" "You're mad that Hotch and I controlled our micro expressions at the hospital, and you weren't able to detect our deception." "You think this is about my profiling skills?" "Jennifer, listen, the only reason you were able to manage my perceptions is because I trusted you." "I came to your house for ten weeks in a row crying over losing a friend, and not once did you have the decency to tell me the truth." "I couldn't." "You couldn't, or you wouldn't?" "No, I couldn't." "What if I started taking Dilaudid again, would you have let me?" "You didn't." "I thought about it." "Spence..." "I'm sorry." "It's too late, all right?" "Reid?" "Oh, you know, Cy, why don't you just crash here?" "I may for a bit." "If Mom and Dad were alive, they'd make you." "You've gotta try and have a nice life." "I have a nice life." "When things get bad, I go out on a ship made of clay." "Of clay, Cy?" "Last night I took another girl out on it." "Yeah?" "When can we meet her?" "Never." "She's dead to me." "(footsteps on staircase)" "TAMMY:" "What do you think?" "I lightened my hair in your honor, Mom." "(Lyla squeals)" "MATT (echoes):" "Oh, my, you look beautiful." "(chuckles)" "Where's the camera?" "(squeals) You look just like your mom did in high school." "TAMMY:" "That's 'cause I'm wearing the same dress." "Mom cut it shorter." "So can I stay out till 2:00?" "MATT:" "Yeah, nice try." "You can go to the dance, and then the party at the motel, but Debbie's mom's picking you up at midnight." "Okay." "Okay." "Have fun." "Thank you." "Would have had to have been a woman very close to the unsub to make him react this way." "Then why go after surrogates?" "I don't think we're dealing with a typical homeless person." "He's good with chemicals, owns a car." "I think the only mistake in our profile was assuming there was something wrong with his physical composition." "Reducing him to some sort of stereotype." "You think it's only his mental state?" "I think this guy might be smart enough to use his disability to his advantage so he comes across" "as harmless." "But then when he's alone and the victim rejects him, he goes off." "What if he doesn't live on the street?" "What if he's in a halfway house?" "Garcia, I need a list of halfway houses and mental health centers in the unsub's comfort zone." "Okay." "Five are being sent to your phones." "Which of those were around in the '80s, Garcia?" "There are two in your area." "Morgan and Prentiss take the first." "Dave and I'll take the second." "What about us?" "Stay here and check VlCAP for similar MOs and signatures." "Reid." "If you want to be mad at someone, be mad at me." "I can't;" "I didn't come to your house crying for ten weeks." "I've worked here over 15 years." "There are many people who fit that description." "This guy would be mobile, probably early 40s." "Well, if he's got a car, then he's transitioned out in the last few years." "State budget cuts." "All right, we'll need a list of those names." "Ain't gonna be small." "Hey, Morgan?" "Hmm?" "What do I do about Reid?" "Emily, there's a lot about you being back that's unresolved." "(gasps)" "Are you pissed at me, too?" "Come on, now." "How can I be?" "You're here." "(sighs) Thank you." "Because I know what you went through." "Grief counseling, you carried my coffin." "Yeah, I sure did." "What was in that thing, anyway?" "(chuckles)" "Here you go." "Thank you very much." "Look... just give Reid some time." "He'll be fine." "(phone beeps)" "Thanks." "Yeah, Hotch, it's me, Morgan." "Listen, 19 people entered this house in the '80s and were let out in the last five years." "HOTCH:" "We've got 1 1 from the one we visited." "Send your names to Garcia;" "have her cross-check them against jobs that use sulfuric acid." "All right, we'll start reaching out to the extended families." "Okay." "How's Reid?" "He's angry and frustrated." "I'm surprised everybody isn't." "Ah, some of us had an inkling." "What?" "I'm good at what I do." "So, are you gonna get, uh, psychological counseling for the team, or handle it internally?" "No, I think that if we all just got together, maybe a cooking lesson at" "the home of one of our founders..." "Oh, not you, too." "...could boost morale." "Is this an order?" "No, it's just a..." "It's a very tempered suggestion." "Yeah." "Tempered suggestion." "(laughter and chatter)" "Hey, you all right?" "Uh, yeah." "Thanks, Debbie, I just..." "I just need a minute." "(dance music playing)" "Tammy?" "Uncle Cy?" "What are... what are you doing here?" "I-l-I was just going to buy some... some beer." "You okay?" "No." "Maybe I should take you home." "I don't want to get in trouble with Mom and Dad." "(chuckles) YYou won't." "I-I'll take care of you." "Okay." "MORGAN:" "So we interviewed the 19 people released from the group home;" "none of them fit the profile." "And Dave's still trying to locate the families." "BONNER:" "Tammy Bradstone's parents just filed a report." "Their daughter didn't return from Homecoming last night." "PRENTlSS:" "Her face is similar to our three vics." "She's about the same age." "Well, the after party where she was last seen is smack in the comfort zone." "HOTCH:" "Where are her parents now?" "BONNER:" "They're at the house." "We're bringing her friends in for questioning." "All right, you head over there." "We'll start the interviews here." "I-I see on the news on the TV people question." "They-They-They question why-why people do this." "It's the same reason people do anything, 'cause..." "'Cause they feel like it." "They-They like the way it feels." "When I was a kid, my dog, Poppy, running across the grass." "When I hit her," "I liked that feeling." "That has not changed." "TAMMY:" "Somebody help me!" "(screams)" "(whimpering, crying)" "Uncle Cy?" "What's happening?" "What did you do to me?" "(gasping and sobbing)" "ROSSl:" "So, kids spill out of the motel toward the cars." "If Tammy walked this way, how could she disappear without anyone seeing her?" "Someone would have heard her scream." "That's if she screamed." "Unlike the last three abduction sites, this one's nowhere near public transportation." "Maybe she knew the unsub." "Or thought she did." "What if... what if Tammy was the target all along?" "That would explain the change in the MO." "So, whoever did this knew she was coming here." "(dialing)" "(line ringing)" "Hi, hi, hi." "MORGAN:" "Hey, baby girl." "I need you to work that magic for me." "Anything, my sweetest." "I just opened up Tammy Bradstone's computer." "I want you to check her e-mails, Web searches and anyone she may have Skyped." "GARClA:" "Okay, typing at the speed of thought." "Thanks, mama." "BOY:" "Are you gonna find my sister?" "We're gonna try, little man." "Listen, um, did your sister dye her hair recently?" "Yeah." "To look nice for the Homecoming dance." "She was even gonna wear the same dress my mom did." "Are you sure that Tammy hasn't been behaving differently lately?" "She's 16, so she's pretty closed off." "Your daughter seems to cherish hanging out in groups." "So there's no way she would run off with someone unless she knew them." "What about her computer?" "Nothing out of the ordinary." "And Hotch cleared the boyfriend." "Do you know anyone who is transient or mentally ill?" "Uh, yeah, my brother." "Um, he didn't get enough oxygen to his brain" "when he was born." "What's his name?" "Cy Bradstone." "On the halfway house list, all I got was a Ben Bradstone." "MATT:" "Oh, no, yeah, uh, that's his real name." "Cy's the name he made up." "Where does he live?" "Well, he crashes here from time to time, but he's basically homeless." "His frontal lobe damage is one of the indicators of serial killers." "MATT:" "Cy isn't a serial killer." "He wouldn't hurt anybody, especially not my daughter." "Come on." "Come on!" "(gasps)" "Shh, shh, shh." "Shh." "Just a little bit further." "I want to tell you a story." "Has Cy ever acted inappropriately toward Tammy?" "No, I wouldn't let him in here if he had." "PRENTlSS:" "Okay, so he sleeps here sometimes, and his head is on this side." "That puts the TV out of his sight." "Yeah, and since when is that a crime?" "It just gives him a full view of the kitchen." "Does Tammy cook for him?" "MATT:" "No." "Lyla does." "MORGAN:" "Ma'am... what's your relationship with Cy?" "I've known him since tenth grade." "That was 1985." "He makes you uncomfortable, doesn't he?" "Did you have blonde hair in high school?" "Yes." "What are you getting at?" "Sir, your daughter just dyed her hair blonde." "You allowed her to wear your dress." "I'm just thinking it may have triggered something for Cy." "What happened with you and Cy that made him so angry?" "MATT:" "Honey, what is it?" "When I was 16, my friends and I went to a party after Homecoming." "Everyone had been drinking." "Damn, I'm seeing stars." "Let's play spin the bottle." "When it was your mom's turn, she spun it, and it landed on me." "You should have seen her face." "She... she lit up" "Iike-like a Lite Bright." "LYLA:" "I didn't know what to do." "My friends laughed, but I didn't want to be mean, so I... went in the closet with him." "MORGAN :" "And what happened next?" "LYLA:" "I let him feel me up." "PRENTlSS:" "How did he behave after that?" "He started following me around at school." "Then one day he overheard me tell a friend how gross I thought he was." "How he talked, how he smelled?" "Why didn't you tell me this?" "I was 16." "We had just started dating." "Does Cy know about your recent marital problems?" "Yeah, I..." "I told him a couple months ago." "And then he probably started making advances toward you, which you had to reject." "That's what triggered the killings." "I did this?" "MORGAN:" "No, no, ma'am." "The events did." "Does Cy have a part-time job?" "Yeah, he-he works at a couple garages." "One on Drake, the other on Fourth." "That explains the sulfuric acid." "MORGAN:" "We'll need those addresses." "Okay, excuse me." "Okay, so as long as Tammy doesn't do anything to antagonize him, we might have a chance." "Oh, my God." "It's you." "You're the one that my mom told me about." "Yeah?" "Yes." "You took advantage of her when she was drunk at a party." "No, that..." "That's-that's not true." "Yeah, it is." "That's probably why she won't touch you now." "That-that's why she won't touch me?" "Yeah." "'Cause you forced yourself on her." "(grunts)" "No!" "You shouldn't have done that, Tammy." "You should have kept your mouth shut." "(gasping)" "(screams)" "You won't get away with this, Uncle Cy." "They'll find you." "They can't find me, Tammy." "They're not looking for me." "(chuckles)" "When Cy comes to the house, he gets out of the car, and he goes to the door." "Yeah." "How do you know he's here?" "I can hear his truck." "So, then you head" "to the front door." "Yes." "MATT:" "There you are, Cy." "MORGAN:" "When you open it, what do you smell?" "MATT:" "He smells musty, like he needs to take a shower." "MORGAN:" "Are you sure that's all you smell?" "I smell chemicals." "He smells like chemicals." "What does he do next?" "LYLA:" "He crushes a cup and-and puts it in his bag." "PRENTlSS:" "Where is it from?" "Is there a name on the cup?" "LYLA:" "It's a soda from a coffee shop." "The Way Station." "It's down the street." "Okay, he probably stops there every time he comes here." "What days would those be?" "Monday, Wednesday and Friday, sometimes Saturday." "Which means he'd be coming today." "(dialing)" "I need you to leave a message for him there." "I'm going to go get us something to eat." "Don't worry, Tammy." "There are other sports to play." "(tires squealing)" "Any luck?" "He hasn't been to either of the mechanic shops in the past two months." "ROSSl:" "But the one on Fourth said a bunch of car batteries had gone missing." "(phone ringing)" "What...?" "(second phone ringing)" "Yeah?" "Morgan, it's from a payphone near a coffee shop." "It's him." "(ringing continues)" "Okay, go ahead." "Just like we talked about." "Hello?" "Hi, it's Cy." "Paulie said you were looking for me." "(stifled sob)" "Lyla?" "What's wrong, Lyla?" "Matt got arrested." "CY:" "What?" "WhWhat are you talking about?" "They think that he hurt Tammy." "Oh, God, Cy." "I need you." "Shh, don't... don't cry." "Lyla, don't-don't cry." "Evertyhing's gonna be all right." "LYLA:" "I just, um..." "I need you to, um, come over here and I just..." "I need you to talk." "I need you to hold me." "You..." "You do?" "Yes, Cy." "Hurry, I have no one else to turn to." "I'll be there, Lyla." "I'll be there!" "(hangs up)" "He's coming." "You and Prentiss stay with them." "Morgan and I'll get the front." "(distorted):" "Lyla!" "Lyla!" "Shh..." "Shh, shh, shh." "It's gonna be okay." "Shh, shh." "It's gonna be okay." "MORGAN:" "Cy Bradstone!" "fbi." "Put your hands where I can see 'em!" "Let me see your hands." "Lyla?" "On your knees now!" "How could you do this to me?" "!" "MORGAN:" "Get up." "CY:" "How could you do this to me?" "!" "Stop moving." "Stop it!" "(handcuffs click)" "HOTCH:" "We need to know where Tammy is, Cy." "We've looked in your car." "There's no sign of her." "We know this isn't about Tammy." "This is about your love for Lyla." "Lyla?" "Lie..." "Ia." "ROSSl:" "You and Lyla had a pretty good secret all these years." "How'd she get you to shut up about it?" "(laughs)" "One time." "That's all I needed." "Is that where you, uh, did it, Cy?" "Is that the same place you took Tammy?" "HOTCH:" "We know when you saw her in that dress, it made you think of Lyla." "Tammy's not the one you want to hurt, Cy." "Lyla's the one that should be punished." "She's the one who made you feel like a freak." "ROSSl:" "A reject, a weirdo." "(Cy groans softly)" "Tell us where Tammy is, Cy, and we can be done." "Done?" "Finished." "Finished?" "Well, I can..." "I can do that." "Under one condition." "Where's Tammy, Cy?" "Hey!" "What did you do with my daughter?" "Lyla was an angel," "like..." "like a prize in the Cracker Jack box." "When she would come in..." "into the room, my-my heart would..." "would race." "When I saw Tammy in-in that dress, it took me back there." "Cy... just tell me where she is." "I took her." "We did things." "(Cy laughs)" "Evertyhing was going good un... un-until she said those words." "What did she say, Cy?" "She said... (sighing)" "She said the-the reason her mother always backs up when I came over was because she didn't want to feel me touching her!" "So guess what I did, Matt." "You guess!" "What did you do, Cy?" "I made it so she couldn't feel, either." "(Tammy whimpering, panting)" "(Tammy sniffles, coughs)" "(whimpering)" "Shh, shh, shh, shh, shh." "(sizzling, screaming)" "And she screamed so loud." "But no one could hear her." "Where do you have her?" "The same place I told him about my love." "Guess who I went to second base with?" "Who, Cy?" "Lyla Smith." "Bull!" "Get back here!" "Why don't you believe me?" "'Cause you lie." "You never told me that." "Yes, I did!" "Yes, I did!" "Yes, I did!" "But you thought I was lying, and then you married my girl!" "So this is what you do, Cy?" "!" "Why didn't you just hurt me?" "And take away your senses, Matt?" "The last one is hearing." "If I did that, you wouldn't be able to listen to what I did to her." "You son of a bitch, you taped it." "No, no, no." "You taped my daughter?" "!" "(Cy laughs) You son of a bitch!" "Son of a bitch?" "You son of a bitch!" "(laughing)" "(siren wailing)" "MAN:" "Clear." "She's got a pulse." "I need a medic in here!" "Oh, geez." "(Prentiss sighs)" "ROSSl:" "Scott Adams wrote" ""Nothing inspires forgiveness quite like revenge. "" "(sighs)" "So, the surgeon said he believes he can restore feeling to Tammy's hands." "Good." "We got there in time." "I heard Mr. Bradstone wants to watch the tape." "People have an innate curiosity to see things in order to confirm them." "Well, that explains why I'm going to Rossi's tomorrow night." "I want to see if he really can cook. (laughs)" "You coming?" "I don't know." "I'm not so sure I can make it." "Look, Reid," "I know you're mad at us because we didn't tell you what really happened, and..." "I understand that." "But I promise you, we had no choice." "You mourned the loss of a friend." "I mourned the loss of six." "(sighs)" "This whole thing gave me an ulcer." "Please, don't give me another one." "Are you gonna go to Rossi's tomorrow?" "We'll see." "(Reid quietly clears his throat)" "Now, Matt, you might not want to watch this, but this is what I am going to do to your daughter." "But what I did with your wife-- now that's a tape you should see." "(laughs)" "(Tammy screaming)" "(gasps)" "(screaming continues)" "CY:" "Shh, shh, shh, shh, shh." "Shh, shh, shh..." "(screaming continues)" "("Mambo Italiano" playing)" "ROSSl:" "Cooking is the most sensual art form." "And these are my paints." "So your hands must be brushes." "Don't interrupt." "In a pot of boiling water, we cook our spaghetti until it's al dente-- firm to the tooth." "Here you go." "Everybody, pass it around so you feel the texture." "There we go." "Okay." "(oil sizzling in pan)" "Now, in a large pan, we fry up our pancetta, keeping a sharp eye that the edges are crisp." "But careful not to burn the onions." "Bravo, Aaron." "We sauté until translucence." "(doorbell rings)" "Uh, I got it." "Grazie mille." "Ah, ah, ah!" "?" "Mambo Italiano... ?" "Now..." "(stifled laugh) We mix in the eggs." "?" "Mambo Italiano... ?" "The Parmesan." "The spaghett and parsley." "You see, it's all about timing and rhythm." "And if you don't feel yourself doing it properly," "please..." "(door closes) ...order a pizza." "Sorry I'm late." "Yeah." "And this is why I cook alone." "PRENTlSS:" "So, uh, when do we get to drink the wine?" "Almost there." "Okay." "I start at the beginning." "You eat what you cook." "I'll supervise, but we're gonna do this all together, just" "like... a family." "Okay now?" "?" "Mambo, Mambo Italiano... ?" "Now." "Salute!" "ALL:" "Salute!" "?" "Mambo Italiano, ho, ho, ho ?" "?" "You mixed-up Siciliano... ?" "garcia:" "I'm reaching." "Whoa!" "All right." "(laughter)" "?" "When you Mambo Italiano... ?"